If you wake at two in the morning with a hot pillow under your cheek and flip it over like a burger on a grill, you already know the question this piece is answering. I slept on the QUTOOL Cooling Pillow for nine weeks and on a gel memory foam pillow for two, both on my side of a queen bed in an upstairs room that runs warm from June through September. Here is the short answer. The QUTOOL stayed cooler for longer, meaning it was still bearable at four in the morning when the gel pillow had turned into a warm brick. The gel pillow felt colder in the first twenty minutes and never needed fluffing. Your problem is either falling asleep hot or staying asleep hot, and those two problems do not want the same pillow.

Some context, because it changes how you read the rest. I am 54, retired after twenty-eight years in the school library, and I live outside Harrisburg in a 1960s brick two-story that holds heat upstairs the way a thermos holds soup. My night sweats started around 51. They still wake me a few nights a week, not every night, which is somehow more irritating than a steady pattern because I can never plan around them. Rick, my husband, is 57 and sleeps cold. He wants a blanket in July. We have a queen bed, one window air conditioner, and a ceiling fan, and the two of us have been negotiating the thermostat for six years. So when I say I tested a pillow, I mean I tested it in a real bed, next to a cold-sleeping man, with one aging air conditioner doing its level best.

QUTOOL Cooling PillowGel Memory Foam Pillow
Cooling surfaceDouble-sided cover with a silky ice fabric on one face that the listing says lowers surface temperature by about 4 to 9 degrees Fahrenheit, and a soft face on the otherA gel layer or gel beads on one face; cool to the touch when you lie down
Loft and fillShredded memory foam you can take out or add back, so you set the height yourselfOne solid piece of foam; the height is the height
Temperature at 3 a.m.Noticeably cooler than a standard pillow through most of the night, though not cool to the touch by morningWarm by the third or fourth hour in my testing
First twenty minutesComfortable and mild, not startlingly coldCold right away, which is the whole reason people buy it
Holding its shapeThe fill shifts; it wants a fluff and a shove most morningsHolds its shape with nothing to fluff and nothing to rearrange
Out of the boxAllow about one or two days of airing out before sleeping on itSleepable the same night
WashingCover only, machine wash, air dry with no heat, and the inner filling never goes in the machineCover only in most cases, and the foam core never goes in the machine
Best forHot sleepers who are also particular about pillow heightSleepers who run hot only at the start of the night and want a fixed, firm pillow

What a Cooling Pillow Can and Cannot Do

The QUTOOL listing says the ice-silky side of the cover helps lower surface temperature by about 4 to 9 degrees Fahrenheit. I believe that as far as it goes, and the same listing is honest enough to point out that all fabrics used on bedding are affected by the temperature of their surroundings. That sentence is the whole ballgame. A pillow is not a refrigerator. It is a surface that either moves heat away from your head faster than an ordinary cotton case or it does not, and the room gets a vote.

In my house the surroundings are a window air conditioner set to 68 and a ceiling fan on low. With both running, the QUTOOL felt cool when I got in and stayed noticeably cooler than my old pillow for most of the night. On the two nights I tried it with the air conditioner off, it was still better than the alternative and it was not cool by three in the morning, because the room was 81 degrees and nothing short of a cold shower was going to fix that.

There is a second layer to this that nobody mentions in the product photos. Heat comes up from the mattress and sideways from the sheets, and a pillow sits in the middle of all of it. If the mattress pad under you is holding warmth, a cool pillow is one cool object in a warm bed. So the honest framing is this: a cooling pillow buys you time. It does not buy you a cool room, and it does not buy you a cool bed.

A hand pressing into the corner of a pillow on a made bed beside a nightstand with a glass of water, soft morning light from a window.

How I Ran the Test

Two weeks per pillow, same sheets, same fan speed, same air conditioner setting, and a notepad on the nightstand where I wrote down the time every single time I woke. I am not a scientist and I am not a doctor. I am a retired librarian with a bad memory and a strong opinion about sleep, and the notepad is the only reason I trust any of this. If your night sweats are new, heavy, or come with other symptoms, talk to your own doctor, because there are causes worth ruling out and I am not the person to rule them out.

What the notepad showed: on the gel pillow I woke an average of twice a night, almost always around the three or four hour mark, and the first thing I did was shove the pillow away from my face. On the QUTOOL I woke about once, and on the good nights I woke at five and realized I had not thought about the pillow at all. That is not a cure. It is a smaller problem, which is what most of us are actually shopping for.

On the gel pillow I woke twice a night and shoved it away from my face. On the QUTOOL I woke once, and at five in the morning I realized I had not thought about the pillow at all.

Where QUTOOL Wins

The fill is shredded memory foam, about 85 percent cross-cut foam and 15 percent soft microfiber, and the cover unzips so you can take fill out or put it back. I removed roughly two handfuls and ended up with a pillow low enough that my shoulder could drop instead of being pushed up around my ear. On the gel pillow there is no such negotiation. The foam is one solid piece, the loft is the loft, and if it sits half an inch too tall for your shoulder you are stuck with it or you are driving back to the store. For anyone whose shoulders have opinions after fifty, that adjustability is the whole argument.

The cover has two faces. One is the silky ice fabric and one is soft, and in October, when the upstairs finally cooled off, I flipped the whole pillow over and used the soft side. That sounds like a small thing and it is not, because a pillow that only does cooling is a pillow you stop using in September and start resenting by November. The cover is 350 thread count and machine washable, with the usual caveat that the filling stays out of the machine.

The queen set is two pillows, and the second one went to Rick, who has opinions about pillows and shares none of them. His is on the soft side and he has stopped borrowing mine, which after six years of thermostat negotiations counts as a diplomatic breakthrough. The pillows are rectangular and the pair weighs about 7.3 pounds, light enough to move around at two in the morning without waking anybody. They are built for side, back, and stomach sleepers, and I can vouch for side and stomach. The fill cradles the neck instead of levering the head up, so my spine stays lined up rather than bent sideways for eight hours.

A hand flipping a pillow over in a dim bedroom, rumpled sheets and a low bedside lamp.

Where the Gel Memory Foam Pillow Wins

The gel pillow is colder when you first lie down. Not slightly colder. Noticeably colder. There is a reason people buy them, and if your trouble is the twenty minutes it takes to fall asleep while your neck overheats, the gel pillow wins that round without a contest. It feels like relief at exactly the moment you want relief.

The solid foam also holds its shape. Nothing migrates, nothing needs punching back into place in the morning, and the pillow will look the same in year two as it did in week one. The QUTOOL, like every shredded pillow I have owned, wants a fluff and a shove before bed. The other real advantage is timing. You can sleep on a gel pillow the night you bring it home. The QUTOOL asks for about one or two days of airing out first, and if you open the box at ten at night expecting to use it, you are going to be disappointed and a little annoyed.

The Details Nobody Puts on the Box

Care on the QUTOOL is cover only. Machine wash the cover, air dry it with no heat, and never wash the inner filling. I washed mine on a Saturday morning and had it back together by dinner, which is more convenient than my old pillow ever was. The tradeoffs are these: it needs that airing out period, it needs fluffing, and the fill will slowly migrate to whichever end you lean on until you redistribute it. None of those are deal breakers. They are just chores, and you should know about chores before you buy.

On the gel side, the foam core is one piece and the gel is on one face, so flipping it over gets you a plain foam surface. It is heavier than a fiberfill pillow and it does not fold or squish into a ball for travel. The cover washes and the core does not. And because the loft is fixed, you are buying a guess about your own neck. Mine was close. Close is not the same as adjustable.

If you are the one awake at 3 a.m. flipping your pillow, buy the one that is still cool by then

The QUTOOL queen set is two adjustable pillows, one cooling face and one soft face, machine washable cover. I took out about two handfuls of fill and slept through to five for the first time in months.

Check Today's Price on Amazon →

Who Should Buy Which

Buy the QUTOOL if you wake two or three times a night and the pillow is the first thing you notice. Buy it if you are a side sleeper whose shoulder complains, because you can remove fill until the height is right instead of hoping. Buy it if you want one pillow that works in July and again in October by turning it over. And buy it if you and your husband run at different temperatures, because the set gives each of you your own, and that ended a small nightly war in this house.

Buy the gel memory foam pillow if your problem is the first twenty minutes rather than the whole night, if you want a firm pillow with no maintenance and no fluffing, or if you need something you can sleep on tonight. It is a good pillow. It simply assumes your room is already cool, and in my upstairs bedroom in August that assumption did not hold past the fourth hour.

One last thing, and I would feel dishonest leaving it out. The pillow is one piece of the puzzle. The ceiling fan matters. Cotton sheets matter more than I expected. Keeping the bedroom door shut during the day so the upstairs does not bake matters. So does the unglamorous compromise Rick and I landed on, which is a light blanket folded on his half of the bed and nothing on mine. Cooling the sleeper is easier than cooling the bed, and the QUTOOL is the part of that I can point to and say it worked.

Start with the thing your face is pressed against for eight hours

Two adjustable queen pillows with a cooling face and a soft face, 350 thread count cover, machine washable, nothing to plug in. Give it two days to air out and a few minutes to get the fill right, then see how the fourth hour of the night feels.

See the QUTOOL Cooling Pillow on Amazon →